Hacker News

Platform to Validate Ideas?

Hi, I was wondering if people knew of any platform or service whereby you can assess whether people really want your idea (if it exists). I am kind of imagining a "Product Hunt for Solvable Problems" - where people can approve or disprove relevant startup ideas. This is an idea within itself, but I was curious to understand how people currently go about the initial validation process and whether any tool remotely similar exists (it would be very useful right about now!). Thanks :)

4 pointsabriscallbowker posted 2 months ago6 Comments
jppope said 2 months ago:

The best way is to go talk to people.

Though Tech People hate the concept there is no better way to validate an idea. Why? because people are willing tell you why they don't want to buy you thing or why they do, which lets you develop better products

abriscallbowker said 2 months ago:

Good Advice! Do you have any recommendations for how to gain a grasp of what problem to solve in the first place - how do I know where to begin and what users to speak to?

jppope said 2 months ago:

I'd recommend finding people that are already good at isolating these sorts of problems themselves, they'll either have one queued up for you or show you how to find them.

Be careful about not talking to someone thats too successful though- they are playing a different game and their knowledge probably won't be applicable at lower levels (i.e. don't a formula 1 driver how to parallel park)

erikbrodch said 2 months ago:

This is from a post I wrote:

A few ways to 'find a problem':

1. Think about what’s broken in the industry you worked at or have expertise in. Make a list of all the things your previous employer lost money over (employees’ time is probably the most expensive resource). This list is essentially a list of potential companies. If for example, you were in the fashion industry, you might be able to come up with ways to solve the guesswork fashion brands need to do in order to keep up with the market trends.

2. Build something that solves a problem for you. Many companies started that way. Say you are trying to go on a keto diet, and you found a way that makes it easier. Chances are many other people would find it helpful and be willing to pay for it.

3. Research. You might know a specific demographic is experiencing several difficulties, but you don’t know exactly what’s the core problem. Start reading and writing about it. When I started Spectroomz I didn’t know it’s going to be a freelancing platform for autistic people. My son is autistic so I started researching on Reddit what would be his future biggest challenges. You can passively research (i.e. read), or do so actively (I actually posted that question on Reddit r/aspergers). Once I got a sense that one of the main challenges is employment, I started searching for more content on Google Scholar, corresponding and chatting with other autistics about it and more.

4. Important reading - Paul Graham wrote a great post on how to come up with startup ideas. http://www.paulgraham.com/startupideas.html

After you find the problem, talk to users as jppope said. In the blog post I share a format of how to talk to users which I simply summarized from a YC startup school lecture - https://spectroomz.typeform.com/to/HR5R10

If you have several ideas and want to assess what has most potential, you can use a startup evaluation tool I created (also following a YC startup school lecture) - https://spectroomz.typeform.com/to/imIL7z

Hope this helps.

abriscallbowker said 2 months ago:

Thanks for all the insight, certainly helpful!

said 2 months ago: