Hacker News

vector_spaces said a year ago:

A while ago I built a simple SMS bot for my partner and I to track finances like this, and it works fairly well. The workflow is whenever we spend money we text it with "spend <amount>" or "sp <amount>", and whenever we receive money we do "add <amount>", and "save <amount>" whenever we move money to savings.

I added some minimal polish like an undo command, a minimal GUI accessible via a short-lived link it sends us on request where we can add and edit recurring bills, subscriptions, and upcoming one-time or yearly major expenses. It has support for debts/loans (we can do "cc <debt> <amount>" for increasing debt, e.g. by paying with a credit card, and "pay <debt> <amount>" for payments). It sends us nightly and weekly reports letting us know progress towards savings goals and warning us if we're about to run into a tight spot based on what it knows about our spend rate, and upcoming bills and big expenses. It also bugs us if it notices we haven't transferred anything to savings recently.

The fact that it doesn't sync automatically with our bank accounts is actually a feature, because the ritual of having to text it whenever we spend money forces some mindfulness of our spending habits, and the regular reports (where it chides us if we're not saving much or exceeding our spending goals) add some gamification -- we joke about how we want to make it proud of us. :)

swsieber said a year ago:

Shameless plug - I wrote a SaaS that's pretty much just a SMS <-> google spreadsheet mapper. https://byobudget.com

That said, yours looks a lot more full-fledged than mine. Mine can only record transactions and then send a response (which it reads calculated from the spreadsheet based on the last transaction, which I'm very proud of for the level of customization it provides), but I've been noodling over how to add custom commands.

FTR, I shameless stole my idea from an earlier HN comment sometime last year; if you're considering implementing a SMS/spreadsheet system yourself, I'd check it out https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17313321

Edit: I really am happy with my solution because it basically lets you take any google sheets based transaction you have and add SMS as an input method.

Edit 2: Sorry if you encounter any rough edges if you go to use BYOB - I haven't marketed it widely, but my wife and I do use it. Any feedback is very much welcome.

Edit 3: If you don't want the manual import of transactions (but do want the freedom of a spreadsheet) then I'd suggest TillerHQ instead https://tillerhq.com I haven't used em, but I came across them when doing research before launching BYOB.

vector_spaces said a year ago:

haha, I actually saw that comment shortly after I wrote the first version of mine. Did some searching on HN to see if anyone else was doing something like this -- it made me feel a little less weird about my idea to know that someone else was, in fact. Cool to know that you are too!

I also like that yours is generic -- I'm curious what other use cases might exist for an SMS based query system for sheets.

Another minor feature I added was lists so that my partner and I could keep our shopping list synchronized -- I could imagine it working well for that too

swsieber said a year ago:

Well, I like the idea of timer to watch stuff. I could see it being a 3-7 day timer to trigger a text if you haven't updated the spreadsheet in some way.

As for queries, I'd like to add queries to get the categories and query the amount left in a category. But that's more special casing - maybe it's a purist in me. I'm leaning towards letting people define a keywords area with three columns - the first is the word to trigger the command, the second is where anything after the keyword gets put (in some sanitized manner - like stripping whitespace) and the third would be the place to read the response.

I like the shopping list idea.

I haven't really taken the time to polish up some operational bits (we have really good logging/metrics where I work, and I miss it) or to market it though. So it's basically just my wife and I right now. I think the push to get something shipped (and my perfectionism) drained me, but reading this stories comments has been invigorating, and I an probably go about improving things in a more measured manner.

wolfgang000 said a year ago:

WoW, your app is exactly what I had been looking for, most budgeting apps have gorgeous Graphs and stats but keeping it updated is really annoying, using SMS as the medium is genius. In fact, when I got some free time I'm going to make my own version but with WhatsApp or telegram on top of the SMS.

WorldMaker said a year ago:

Yeah, I'm thinking something along the lines of using Bot Framework maybe to maximize the number of possible message platforms. You could also easily see it as a "skill" for Alexa/Cortana/et al, too.

mjparrott said a year ago:

You can make a google form that accepts the same information and then stores it in a sheet. You put a link to the form on your phone. Easy, free, integrated solution.

buzzy_hacker said a year ago:

Nice! I use YNAB and have an AWS environment set up that logs all my credit card transactions instantly. My bank sends me an email with the transaction info, which I receive with Simple Email Service. Then I use Lambda to parse the email and log it in YNAB using their API. Fun and useful project. https://github.com/buzzlawless/ynab-live-import

I totally get the benefits of ritually entering though. I’m definitely lazier about non-credit card transactions now... motivation to expand my program to other types of accounts and get fully automated!

LilBytes said a year ago:

Wow, that's amazing. I'm totally going to use this. YNAB unfortunately don't allow live feeds from Australian banks so using middle-ware is a great idea. I never even considered broking the service myself. Awesome!

buzzy_hacker said a year ago:

Thanks! Glad to hear others are getting use out of this idea. Feel free to ask any questions if you run into stumbling blocks setting it up.

LilBytes said a year ago:

I surely will, thanks again!

4k05 said a year ago:

I do something similar. Banks in Germany offer a so called HBCI/FinTS interface (I think it is mandatory for them). There are some open source libraries available to read transaction through this interface. I made a time triggered azure function to read all transactions from the bank for the day before and add them to YNAB via their REST API. Was a fun weekend projet...

We then add categories manually to all transaction on the YNAB app, so... we go through each transaction every couple of days.

chrisked said a year ago:

Curious to know which free libraries you are using. Additionally appreciate a comment about reliability. Cheers!

qTY67B said a year ago:

Hey! Which library to interact with the HBCI/FinTS interface are you using?

ryanianian said a year ago:

My partner and I have been happy users of GoodBudget.com for a while for this purpose. (Not affiliated just a happy user.) It's an envelope-budget SaaS product and has many of these features minus the SMS and open-source things

DLarsen said a year ago:

I've setup something very similar at my hobby project spendlight.com. The public site is now largely neglected with too many placeholder images, but I landed at the same conclusion that no sync is a feature... because mindful spending.

vector_spaces said a year ago:

Nice landing page! I actually like your placeholder images :)

dhshahsndeisjwn said a year ago:

This sounds cool... have you shared the code anywhere?

vector_spaces said a year ago:

Thanks! I haven't yet, mainly because I want to clean some things up first -- for instance, it's currently writing to a JSON file, with a job that archive a copy of it every few hours in case it gets corrupted.

Which is probably totally fine for most use cases, but I plan to port it to SQLite and open source it soonish.

jonaf said a year ago:

I have been in search of what you’ve put together. My wife and I have tried unsuccessfully various strategies along these lines that were more lofi, but always come back to the spreadsheet. Another vote for open sourcing! I would be willing to contribute in my spare time to something like this. It’s a big gap for many, and all these beautiful iOS apps fall short in every way (but mainly I can’t bring myself to put my bank info on any of them!!).

switz said a year ago:

Open source it now and someone might add different storage adapters -- you have eyes on it.

cbsks said a year ago:

+1 for please open source it! That sounds like my ideal budget tracker.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Not the author of this post, but I am the author of My Budget. I saw this post and said, "Hey - I know that name!"

Thanks for sharing again. If you want to get in touch with me, there is also a Slack you can reach me "zachary" at (https://join.slack.com/t/my-budget/shared_invite/enQtNjA0NDg...)

pard68 said a year ago:

Didnt see it in the readme or wiki/faq, what budget method does this use?

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

It's taken mostly from EveryDollar, or envelope-budgeting if that is a good analogy.

pard68 said a year ago:

Thanks, exactly what I was hoping for!

rootkea said a year ago:

But why Slack though? Can't we have a IRC/matrix channel?

jldugger said a year ago:

I use GNUCash, and despite it's substantial shortcomings, the regular flow of competition never quite hits the mark. Here's a small sample of what features I'm looking for:

1. Transaction import. OFX at a minimum, but preferably an online pull that can be automated. Many banks do support online pulls -- for example GNUcash calls out to aqbanking, with an incredibly obtuse UI, and is an area for improvement.

2. multiple accounts and currencies. I need to be able to track investments and assets. That means multiple accounts, denominated in different and possibly custom units. GNUCash allows multiple accounts and multiple currencies, but you cannot put different currencies in your own account. The work around is subaccounts per stock ticker etc., but it seems like improvements could be made here.

3. Synchronization. In my view, 'offline' is synonymous with 'disposable.' I have many years of history, and it would be unfortunate to lose it in a drive failure. I have this backed by a personal SQL server, but many people use dropbox style sync. Multiuser would be an area of improvement here.

The one thing I'm not looking for is budgeting. A ledger is basically a budget with dates per item, so why not just go directly to the ledger form? Salary, mortgage payments, rent, insurance, and streaming subscriptions are all predictable expenses, just slap em into the ledger ahead of time. Even the variable stuff like dining is a bit more predictable with a credit card.

The above should not be a knock to the many other systems, so please don't bother to try selling me on ledger-cli =)

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget.

These are all good things to have, several of them are already on my roadmap (https://github.com/reZach/my-budget/wiki/FAQ#future-features).

If you'd like to offer more suggestions, please come to the slack and talk to me "zachary" there, thanks! (https://join.slack.com/t/my-budget/shared_invite/enQtNjA0NDg...)

thrownthrow said a year ago:

I use GNUcash for business too, but use git as storage/sync instead.

Also a simple fast tool with some handy little reports and graphs is http://homebank.free.fr/en/ We still use this for our personal finances.

hellofunk said a year ago:

How do you find GNUcash? I looked at it awhile back and found the UI so antiquated compared to modern tools, but I'd prefer something different than the commercial provider I'm using now.

jldugger said a year ago:

Honestly, I suspect if you changed a few icons and made the default theme more blue and less green, it'd look a lot more modern.

Edit: or maybe a cool 'dark' themed version.

cascom said a year ago:

The UI may be antiquated but it does what it needs to without any lock-in, and you have control of your data. Plus you can do you accrual based accounting which just makes so much more sense (I may pay my car insurance premium once a year, but it is a monthly expense)

shashank said a year ago:

Buxfer (https://www.buxfer.com) has almost all of what you mention: import (can be automated via API), automatic pull from banks, multiple currencies, backup to cloud (although it's not a "backup and restore", it's backup so you can have your data with you in a standard format.)

Disclosure: I'm the founder.

cfontes said a year ago:

Hey I used buxfer for years when I was trying to control my finances and learn my patterns during college and first jobs.

It was great, I liked it so much that even on a super shitty exchange rate for me I became a subscriber at the time, even though I didn’t need the subs features.

I don’t use it anymore, maily because I can do it in my head now + the little tools my bank provides, but thanks man. Your service made me a better human.

shashank said a year ago:

It's always immensely satisfying to hear a personal story of my work benefitting another fellow human being. Thanks for sharing!

akerro said a year ago:
powersurge360 said a year ago:

This is very exciting for me, thank you for sharing.

taysix said a year ago:

This looks awesome. Thank you for sharing.

0xffff2 said a year ago:

The reason I continue to use Quicken rather than writing my own tool that I'm sure doesn't sell my data is that it allows me to relatively painlessly sync transactions from my bank. This is largely my bank's fault for not exposing some kind of API I can hook into, but nonetheless any budgeting app that doesn't sync transactions from most financial institutions is not a "solution".

Just based on the single screenshot in the readme, it seems like the workflow needs work too. The information density in the screenshot looks painfully low to me.

brundolf said a year ago:

There's a hack I worked out years ago where you set up a dummy email account and have your bank notify it by email every time there's a transaction over $0.01. Do a little HTML crawling and you've got a transactions database.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget.

I'm currently working to get OFX supported, which is the "automatic API" that can scrape your transactions. Quicken uses this, falling back on screen scraping in case OFX isn't supported.

There are a number of features that I'd still like to add (documented here: https://github.com/reZach/my-budget/wiki/FAQ#future-features). Are there specific things you'd like to see that I can put on my roadmap?

indemnity said a year ago:

OFX is a painful spec; hard to know what is and is not used by various banks.

I spent a bit of time writing a simple streaming OFXv1 (SGML) parser in Rust, but I'm too ashamed to open-source it. The idea behind it was you read the OFX file byte by byte, using Nom to parse out tokens, and emit events when you hit SGML tags and element content (SAX-parser style). Then you have something over the top of that that accumulates state until it has a complete OFX data element, and then emits that.

Advantage: Very low memory usage. Disadvantage: Probably overkill, since OFX files probably wouldn't be megabytes or gigabytes.

It works for my bank feed, but who knows how many other banks!

If you have any ideas on how to support this well in a non-hacky way that doesn't involve relying on a scripting language (all other existing implementations seem to be some form of scripting language :().

kibibyte said a year ago:

> Probably overkill, since OFX files probably wouldn't be megabytes or gigabytes.

Maybe not gigabytes, but if you wanted to pull transaction-level data from a relatively active brokerage account, you could end up with an OFX file of a couple of megabytes. I'm sure someone might appreciate the efficiency.

tekknolagi said a year ago:

Please open source it! I'm sure people would be delighted to contribute once you do.

0xffff2 said a year ago:

The one specific thing that stands out to me besides sync support is user-interface optimization. In Quicken I can see and edit my entire monthly budget on a single page, including adding/removing categories, seeing current spending/income for all categories, and editing spending/income targets. The screenshot in the readme prioritizes things I rarely care about (editing categories, individual transactions) instead of the things that I do care about (big picture view of my current/planned budget).

Canadauni said a year ago:

Have you looked into the plaid[0] free(test) tier? They hook into a bunch of different banks and the free tier exposes balance and transaction history.


vlucas said a year ago:

If you have a free Plaid account, you might check out BudgetSheet: https://www.budgetsheet.net

It imports live bank transactions into a Google Sheet for you to use however you want.

techsupporter said a year ago:

I really wish I could find a service that would do this for something other than Google Sheets (or like Tiller using a Google login even though they can write to Microsoft's OneDrive...for some reason). The last place I want to store a bunch of sensitive financial information is Mint. The second last is Google.

To that end, I looked into using Plaid's API to craft my own but it's a bit daunting, especially with a couple of my financial institutions continually failing and having to be reauthenticated, so I don't envy these developers their tasks.

vlucas said a year ago:

Where else would you want this imported? What other products do you use that you would wank your bank transactions in that you trust?

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Their free tier is only 100 "imports". After that, you are looking to pay $500 USD/mo. for unlimited - which simply isn't an option for a free app.

lprd said a year ago:

Do you know if they work with EU banks? I'm in France and this looks really interesting...

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget here. Can you send me a message on the Slack channel (https://join.slack.com/t/my-budget/shared_invite/enQtNjA0NDg...) "zachary" and we can talk about more details.

jeroenhd said a year ago:

Depending on your bank you might be able to import transactions with the tool I use for my finances (https://firefly-iii.org/): it can import using the Spectre/Salt Edge API or through CSV files.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

There is now a wiki page on how to use the app. There is a link in the "Help" menu while using My Budget that takes you to this page: https://github.com/reZach/my-budget/wiki/New-user's-guide.

procinct said a year ago:

How does Quicken sync transactions without a bank API? Do you have to give it your bank credentials so it can scrape the site?

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Yes, that is one of the ways Quicken scrapes information.

The "bank API" is actually OFX, it's a protocol banks use to send each other data. I'm currently working on trying to get OFX support in My Budget. (I'm the author of the Github project).

procinct said a year ago:

It seems insane that people would be okay with their bank credentials being stored in plaintext.

I signed up for a budgeting service that claimed real time transaction sync and immediately unsubscribed when I realised it was planning to do so by scraping.

0xffff2 said a year ago:

Quicken at least claims to store the credentials locally and encrypted. How well it does this I don't know of course, but I consider it infinitely better than any online service, which is why I still use it despite the fact that it manages the impressive feat of being so slow that a web-based service would probably be faster in terms of UI performance.

chiph said a year ago:

People give their passwords to Mint, and I totally don't understand that.

acct1771 said a year ago:

The banks in the US won't cooperate, according to everyone I've heard stories from who are trying to break into, or have broken into, this space.

procinct said a year ago:

That’s still not a good reason to give your bank credentials and allow them to be stored in plain text. At that point if it’s your only option you just don’t do it.

swsieber said a year ago:

TillerHQ does syncing with a google spreadsheet.

powersurge360 said a year ago:

How does this compare to things like beancount or ledger cli? Did you look at those and find them wanting?

Personally I've used ledger and loved it but found it a bit of a pain to get going due to its manual nature and it also created a bit of a firewall for my SO because she's not inclined to spin up a terminal to look at the finances. I liked beancount for its facilities to do automatic imports but I found its reporting lackluster.

I liked hledger most of all but to compile it was kind of a pain and it had many of the same complaints as ledger although its reporting and especially budgets were top notch.

kiney said a year ago:

I use beancount in combination with the fava web-ui. Best of both worlds (plaintext/gui).


BeetleB said a year ago:

Beancount's budgeting capabilities are virtually nonexistent (despite what the author keeps claiming).

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget.

I'd like to incorporate reports, that is something that is in my roadmap. Are there other features of beancount or ledger cli that you'd like to see in My Budget?

l8nite said a year ago:

I'd love to see an open source YNAB clone... maybe this can be evolved in that direction! Well done.

obelos said a year ago:

Not open source, but https://financier.io/ is browser-based YNAB clone. I'm still using YNAB4 for the time being, but will probably switch to Financier once YNAB4 stops working.

EDIT: Looks like it's been updated to be an open source project: https://blog.financier.io/financier-is-now-open-source-bdfe9...

Kovah said a year ago:

Financier looked absolutely great when I tested it a few months ago. But: lot of features missing (like recurring transactions) and the app seems to be abandoned. At least there was no activity for over a year now. What a pity.

georgebcrawford said a year ago:

IIRC, it's not so much abandoned as in what the author considers a finished state. I still use it and actually just paid another year's subscription.

Like you say, there are some missing features, but it does what I need it to perfectly.

asdff said a year ago:

There's a google sheet floating around reddit that's pretty much a YNAB clone. I just use an excel spreadsheet thats formatted to take a copy paste from my bank/cc .csv transaction list, then I go through and categorize the transactions for the past month. Takes 10 mins or so.

I used to use mint which was more automatic, but things rarely get categorized correctly, and by doing it by hand, I'm a lot more aware of my spending habits than if I just looked at some pie charts. I can still make pretty charts in excel if I ever wanted too.

seveneightn9ne said a year ago:

That was my idea behind https://github.com/seveneightn9ne/dino-budgeter - you can try it out at https://dino.jesskenney.com/ - it's missing a lot of the sort of guidance/hand-holding that YNAB provides, and so far it only has the features I personally wanted, but it's at least been enough for me :)

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget.

I'm taking inspiration from YNAB, as it has a rich feature set. Also open source so that's a plus! Thanks!

vijaybritto said a year ago:

Im starting a Flutter course today. This app will be one of my first attempts at non-electron desktop apps. Lets see how this goes!

pxtail said a year ago:

Are you going to put it on github? I bought Flutter course as well (the one from appbrewery recommended on googleblog [0]) but haven't got time to get started with it yet.

[0] https://developers.googleblog.com/2019/05/Flutter-io19.html

vijaybritto said a year ago:

same stuff!! Im going to put it for sure!

zallarak said a year ago:

good time to plug a great paid option: https://actualbudget.com/

Isn0gud said a year ago:

It is free to use locally, only the sync feature is a paid upgrade. And the data stays local.

tomcam said a year ago:

Congratulations! Releasing a significant piece of work is always an amazing time. Would love to see some screenshots in the README showing what makes it unusual, or what the typical workflow is like.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget here.

All good suggestions, thank you. Workflows and guides are what My Budget is lacking, as more core features are being built out. They are on my to-do for the app.

The unique features are: - It's offline (we aren't saving any information about your budget) - Your data can be optionally encrypted at-rest - Limited support to auto-sync your transactions from your bank

A typical workflow for version 3.0.0-beta+ is to add your sources of income. Then, add categories of transactions you have (by category and subcategory). Next, add transactions based upon your categories and subcategories.

Reports and other features like multi-currency/account/users are coming soon.

cottsak said a year ago:

I only skimmed the code, but when it's encrypted, is the only key/input that iv that you've got in the source there?

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

The data is encrypted using the Crypto library from Node (https://nodejs.org/api/crypto.html#crypto_crypto_createciphe...).

The passphrase and IV are used to encrypt/decrypt the data using the aes-256-cbc algorithm (https://github.com/reZach/my-budget/blob/master/app/crypto/c...).

brundolf said a year ago:

Kind of ugly, but that's easy to fix. Great project given that services like Mint are just data vacuums.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget here.

Ah, thanks - I thought I improved it from earlier versions. What in specific do you not like about it? Specific things can help development further.

brundolf said a year ago:

I'm not a trained designer, but just looking at the screenshot in the readme:

- The orange and the purple are both very bold, non-standard colors. Using one or the other makes sense as a way to draw attention to important things and give the tool personality, but having both together is a little grating. Perhaps the orange should be replaced by red? This would also be idiomatic in terms of what those buttons seem to be doing.

- I think there are too many different shades of grey; the title bar, the main background, the white sections, and the category headers are all different shades. Also, something feels off about the color on the category headers. I think part of it is you have white text on a medium-gray background, which isn't quite enough contrast, but part of it may also just be the fact that those headers are darker than the "main" background color. On the other hand, it could look good to just use the title bar color on the category headers. Hard to say without trying it out.

- The transactions table could use a proper border all the way around (it's visibly absent on the top and sides).

- A clearer division could be made (a border line or just a bigger gap) between the "categories" and "transaction" sections, because it's not immediately clear what "delete all" will be deleting.

- The "delete all" and "add new" buttons aren't aligned with the left and right bounds of their section; also, there's no reason for them to be spread out so far. They could gravitate to the right, for example.

- Bolding the field labels below the word "transactions" would make it slightly clearer what purpose they serve, and vertical-aligning them with their respective fields would be slightly more pleasing.

- Making the gap beneath each "sub-category +" larger than the gap above it would help connect it to the table it pertains to.

This is a great further resource on usage of color: https://material.io/design/color/#color-usage-palettes

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

I took a bunch of your suggestions in the latest version: https://rezach.github.io/my-budget/

brundolf said a year ago:

Unfortunately I think changing the category header text to black with the same background may have made that part worse; I'd probably make the text white again and the background the same color as the bar at the very top

The layout is much easier to follow, though

trevor-e said a year ago:

Yea, no offense intended with this, my first thought looking at the project is that it's a scam or malware. I would have to personally read through the source code to feel comfortable using this. The main thing is none of the text is vertically centered and everything is lowercased. Maybe I'm just paranoid about financial software.

brundolf said a year ago:

To be fair one should audit any no-name app that wants to access your bank information, no matter what it looks like.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

I would do the same.

Accessing your bank information is optional, and only works for Discover right now.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Noted, I will consider updating the text to something more formal. Others have said that because it is in lowercase, it isn't as trustworthy. Thanks

1023bytes said a year ago:

Wouldn't it be better just to put it up on Github Pages? It could have all the same functionality as a PWA.

That way anyone could use it instantly, instead of having to download this massive Electron app.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget.

I never thought of that.. it can be an option, although it wouldn't work if you ever lost internet. I'll consider it!

nydel said a year ago:

As one person very interested in using MyBudget, I want to add that I would definitely prefer not to use Electron; but I am admittedly interested enough to go ahead and do it anyway. Once it's up and running this does seem to be the best FLOSS GUI budgeting software I've yet used.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Thanks for your input, and trying it out. I'm trying to continuously improve the software.

groovybits said a year ago:

In the screenshot provided in the README, I see there is a 'sync' button next to the 'save' button. If this is essentially self-hosted, what is the application syncing to?

Edit: Whoops I missed this line under "Features":

> Limited* support to sync transactions with your bank. See here[1] for more details.

1: https://github.com/reZach/my-budget/wiki/Creating-a-new-conn...

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author of My Budget.

Sync is meant to sync transactions from your bank. Right now it has rudimentary screen scraping, and since I don't have infinite throughput, I wrote a way for others to create these methods for their own bank. Once it's working, I can add it into the app and others can use.

I'm trying to get OFX support, which is the much-requested "auto syncing" feature that everyone wants.

bumpkinjunkie said a year ago:

I like this idea. You shouldn't have to pay to access your own bank data. Looking forward to the near future when banks either have an API or die a slow death.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

OFX is the API they use. You need specific credentials that can be found online. If a bank doesn't offer OFX support, you can use the tried-and-true method of web scraping the information out, which is what Quicken does as a last-resort.

app4soft said a year ago:

> offline cross-platform

Electron... "my-budget-3.0.1-beta-x86_64.AppImage" size ~ 161 MB

I prefer Eqonomize, that is Qt5-based. "Eqonomize-1.3.4.AppImage" size ~ 23 MB

[0] https://github.com/Eqonomize/Eqonomize/

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Author here of My Budget.

Yes, that is one of the things I'd like to reduce. I will be focusing on reducing the size of the app. The app you linked, looks nice too.

app4soft said a year ago:

> Yes, that is one of the things I'd like to reduce

Rewriting My Budget from JavaScript to C++ would be hard.

ElijahLynn said a year ago:

I am looking for a spreadsheet that does similar things but also does forecasting with charts too. I want it to be a spreadsheet though. If anyone knows of an open project for this please hook me up!

vlucas said a year ago:

Hey - I am the author of BudgetSheet ( https://www.budgetsheet.net/ ). It is a Google Sheets add-on that links to your own Plaid account to auto-import transactions, and all the data is all stored in the spreadsheet itself so there is no other web service involved.

I don't have any charts or graphs yet, but it is relatively straightforward to make them in a spreadsheet with data that has dates and numbers like the transactions do. Check it out (free for one account), and maybe I can help you with some charts. Email me at vance [at] vancelucas [dot] com or ping me on Twitter at @vlucas if you want to chat about it. I'd love to hear your ideas.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

I'm working on creating reports, which would act on historical data. Forecasting is something I haven't yet thought about, or how that might work. Care to give me your thoughts here?

I'm the author of My Budget.

bash-j said a year ago:

I've been using Mishell Budget Calendar for the past 8 years. Nothing beats the calendar UI in my opinion. Makes sense when you think about most income and expenses are recurring events. The balance at the bottom of each day lets you check the future for days where you might be getting close to running out of funds. It might be a simple move the day you pay your utility bill each month, or try adjusting your grocery budget by a few dollars and it shows straight away how that impacts your future balance.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

Super interesting execution, I really like it!

jpb0104 said a year ago:

A subject near and dear. I work on https://budgetmyway.com. Personally been using it for almost ten years to track my expenses. I haven’t been able to get much traction with other users. I would love to know if any of you personal finance folks find it useful. Onboarding and marketing are hard.

c- said a year ago:

161MB MSI for a budgeting app... I know there's a thing as electron bloat but this is kind of all sorts of insane.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

It's mainly electron, but I'll look in the future to cut down the size.

(My Budget author here).

theprotocol said a year ago:

You might be interested in Proton Native (https://proton-native.js.org/#/) which should produce a much more lightweight output and has native controls. I have not used it though so I cannot vouch for whether it is sufficient for your needs.

bobblywobbles said a year ago:

I'd have to see if it has all the building/signing and packaging support as electron. Thanks for linking!

mitul_45 said a year ago:

This looks cool, I've also built something similar for my needs. The difference is, it's a web based app – so I/my wife can add expense on-the-go.

Uses Google Sheets as a database.


baroffoos said a year ago:

I know this is kind of a tired comment but I wonder where desktop GUI toolkits went wrong to end up where "cross platform" has come to be a synonym for electron.

I know if I was building a desktop program I would pick electron but what can real desktop toolkits change to fix this problem?

pjc50 said a year ago:

Largely they can't, other than having a Highlander situation where they fight each other until only one platform remains.

Java went round this circle. First there was AWT: use the platform-native widgets. Of course, this results in your application looking different on every platform in hard-to-predict ways. So people wrote Swing: single non-native GUI that looks the same everywhere. Eventually people got fed up of the poor performance and non-nativeness of Swing, so they wrote SWT (used in Eclipse) which uses the native widgets again.

If your application is native, then it looks different on different platforms - and you have to test and debug on all of them. If it's non-native, it can look the same on all platforms.

tty2300 said a year ago:

Looking different to the native apps isn't even the worst part. Its that a simple notes app is 300mb and after opening a few basic programs you have 10gb of ram used.

Crinus said a year ago:

It might not be so much a toolkit problem as a language or environment or even knowledge problem: someone might not be interested in working with C or C++ or even in anything else they do not already know and if all they know is web stuff then Electron is the path of least resistance. Even if someone is interested in learning something, that doesn't mean they'd be interested in learning and making a project at the same time.

quickthrower2 said a year ago:

I think a React-native type thing for Windows/Mac/Linux would be a big help. I am not sure there is any incentive for anyone to create such a tool though? The problem with Electron is that it is good enough.

vitoc said a year ago:

Maybe check this out too?:


Not just for budgeting, but in the same space! :)

stfwn said a year ago:

I didn't know about Ledger [1], which this is said to be based on. It seems like a proper UNIX tool like Remind [2] but for finance. I would really like to use these types of applications all the time, but either usability suffers a lot or useful principles get lost when trying to integrate them with smartphones and tablets.

[1]: https://www.ledger-cli.org/

[2]: https://jlk.fjfi.cvut.cz/arch/manpages/man/remind.1

solarkraft said a year ago:

Since this is just a web app, how about a mobile version?

> Offline; there is no back-end service saving your data anywhere.

Can I set this up for myself?

paulgrahamisfat said a year ago:

Never used this before.